In January 1844 the Launceston Examiner ran a paragraph on the female factories. It began with the scale of charges for washing and needlework, moved to worries about competition with free labour, and near its end arrived at marriage:

‘Sir Eardley Wilmot from the moment he arrived, has promoted the settlement of prisoner women by marriage, and will doubtless seldom withhold his sanction when a decent husband offers. It is far better to place a woman in charge of a helpmate than to guard her by a policeman.’[1]

Cascades Female Factory
Image: TAHO NS1013-1-48

It is also a tidy statement of policy: convict women were to be married off, and a husband was judged a better guard than a constable. The sentence repays slow reading, because of who does things in it and who has things done to them.

Who has the verbs

Wilmot ‘promotes’ and ‘sanctions.’ A husband ‘offers.’ The woman is ‘settled,’ ‘placed’ and ‘guarded’. She has no verb of her own.

The vocabulary is administrative. ‘Sanction’ is what a governor gives. A ‘decent husband’ is a qualification, and whether the woman thought him decent is not mentioned. The paper adds that a woman is ‘more likely to become a well-conducted person when separated from her companions,’ presumably the other convict women. The next sentence wants all efforts in assigning women to ‘respectable settlers’, and notes that Governor Gipps in New South Wales appeared to be distributing females through the country so that as few as possible remained in the penitentiaries.[2]

The writer is not being hostile to women. He is describing what is ‘far better’ for a convict woman, in a sentence where her opinion plays no part.

The paragraph also keeps odd company. It opens with the pricing of laundry and needlework done in institutions ‘supported by the crown,’ and it closes by citing Dr Lang’s insistence, before the Sydney council, on getting women out to settlers. Charges, institutions and marriage sit in one column. Whatever the Examiner thought of the women, it was writing about where they could be put.

Policy, not opinion

The Examiner gives no source for its claim about Wilmot, so I treat it as the paper’s description of his practice. It fits a pattern, though, that runs well past 1844.

The mechanism was permission. If either party was a convict under sentence, the couple had to obtain the lieutenant-governor’s consent, which was communicated through the head of the convict department. From 1843 the intended marriage, with the names and residences of both parties, had to be notified in three successive issues of the Hobart Town Gazette by the Principal Superintendent of Convicts. Permission to marriage was a form of control of convicts: it was a reward for good behaviour, and an indulgence that could be refused or cancelled.

The 1843 Marriage Act made the Lieutenant-Governor’s consent a precondition of any convict marriage. A convict who swore a false affidavit risked the penalties for perjury, and a minister who married a convict without the consent letter forfeited £500. Felony conviction, with fourteen years’ transportation, awaited anyone who solemnized a marriage without the required banns, licence or certificate.[3]

The incentives pointed the same way. In 1846 Earl Grey’s despatch to Denison set out plans for the female convicts. They were to receive moral and religious instruction and be prepared to become wives and mothers, and they were to be encouraged to form ‘legitimate connections with unmarried convicts.’ The colony’s population was overwhelmingly male, so the pressure to marry was considerable.[4]

In 1848 Comptroller-General Hampton argued that women should be hired out as soon as they arrived and encouraged to marry, since marriage had proved ‘the best instrument of reform’. Denison shared his view.[5]

Anson hulk off Queens Domain
Image:TAHO PH30-1-1980

From 1850 newly arrived women stopped waiting on the hulk Anson for hire. They received probation passes at once, with remission of sentence on offer for good conduct in service or on marriage. In 1851 certain pass-holders were required to serve less time before applying for a ticket-of-leave, if they were well behaved or married.[6]

‘Instrument’ is the word to notice. The woman is the tool in the policy, as she is the object in the newspaper’s sentence. Here is the paradox in print: convict women were collectively regarded as depraved, and were also the means by which moral reform was to be achieved.[7]

The argument was about method

There was a dissenting voice. In February 1844 a correspondent to the same paper complained of the ‘unlimited indulgence’ enjoyed by convicts who married. Marriage, he wrote, released them from common restraints, because ‘the authority of a husband supercedes [sic] that of the law’. Their houses became ‘haunts of vice’, and he put his objection in a line of its own: ‘an amalgamation of vice with vice can never produce virtue.’[8]

The Examiner thinks a husband controls a woman better than a policeman does. The correspondent thinks a husband controls her worse than the law does. Both take control to be the purpose of the exercise. The question in dispute is who ought to hold the leash.[9]

What control looked like

The records show the leash in use. Elizabeth Brongal, who arrived on the Midlothian in 1853, married John King in February 1854. There is no sign that they sought permission. Brongal was sentenced to three months’ hard labour. King, who held a conditional pardon and was no longer subject to convict discipline, was not touched. When her sentence was served she was ‘returned to her husband’.[10]

Conduct record Elizabeth Brongal, per Midlothian 1851
Image: TAHO CON41-1-36, p15

The verb recurs. In January 1854 Isabella Rattray, whose husband had left the colony, was charged with ‘not being under proper control’ and ‘returned to the service of the Crown’. In December 1853 Eliza Thompson, charged by her husband with being out after hours and falsely calling herself free, was admonished and returned to him.[11] The constable in her case had declined to take her into custody when she said she was free, and learned only afterwards that she was a passholder. Husbands who found a wife unmanageable could lay a charge. Margaret Richardson, a ticket-of-leave woman, was charged by her husband in 1844 after he said he had lost all control over her. She answered that he was too idle to work, so she had to keep herself. She was sentenced to six months in the house of correction, with a recommendation that she lose her ticket-of-leave.[12]

Did it work?

Dianne Snowden, in her paper on convict marriage, calls the question of whether marriage reformed women problematic, and the evidence she offers cuts both ways. Irpashy Howlett, a Kent laundress transported in 1843 for robbery with violence, had a gaol report describing her as addicted to drink, a prostitute and a hawker. She married William Hemsley in 1849 and had several children. Her one colonial offence, disturbing the peace, came after the marriage, while she was assigned to her husband.[13] Mary Burgess, an eighteen-year-old potato thief from Carlow, married a cabinetmaker, settled in Launceston and raised a family that became part of the town’s establishment.[14]

Both cases measure the same thing, which is conduct as the authorities recorded it. Neither says whether either woman wanted the husband, or whether the husband in question was the best of the choices on offer.

The said female

So, who asked the women?

All we have to go on are the surviving records: the marriage application, the memorial, the petition to the governor. These documents concentrate on the male convict’s conduct, his location, and on his ability to support a wife. In 1850 Richard March, a ticket-of-leave man, petitioned to marry Susanna Brewer, who was free. He began: ‘Memorialist and the said female have formed a mutual attachment’ (I have modernised the lay-out), and added that he was industrious and ‘thereby capable to support a wife’.[15] Susanna Brewer appears as ‘the said female’, the subject of an attachment and the author of none of the petition’s words.

Persistence suggests that some couples wanted to marry. Catherine Hayes and Patrick Handley applied repeatedly between February 1854 and October 1855 before they were married. Margaret Butler applied three times to marry James Gillam, although on arrival she had told the authorities she had a husband.[16] These applications show women acting. They do not show anyone asking.

I have yet to find any evidence that anyone asked the convict women what they wanted. The Examiner does not mention it. Grey and Hampton wrote of what women should be prepared for and encouraged to do. The newspaper correspondent who disliked the policy objected to its results, and left its premise alone. The words of the women involved were not recorded. What remains is a decade or so of men deciding what was best for convict women, in the language of them being helpmates and instruments, and the women placed in charge of whoever the governor sanctioned.


[1] Launceston Examiner, 6 January 1844, page 3

[2] Launceston Examiner, 6 January 1844, page 3

[3] 1843 Marriage Act, VDL – 6 Vict. No. 18 ss. VIII, X, XIII, XVI and XVII; British Parliamentary Papers, Convict Discipline and Transportation, vol. 7, p. 522 (Grey to Denison, 30 September 1846);

[4] Ian Brand, the Convict Probation System: Van Diemen’s Land 1839 – 1854 (Hobart, 1990), p 68

[5] TAHO GO 33-64, pp. 287–345 (Comptroller-General to Lieutenant-Governor, 30 May 1848).

[6] Launceston Examiner, 24 February 1844, p 3

[7] Dianne Snowden, ‘Convict Marriage: “the best instrument of reform”’, Tasmanian Historical Studies 9 (2004), p 68

[8] Launceston Examiner, 24 February 1844, p 3

[9] Snowden, p 69

[10] Snowden, p. 63, citing AOT, CON 41/36, Elizabeth Brongal, Midlothian 1853, No. 1211; NS 373/1, No. 1104; RGD 37/13, 1854 (Hobart), No. 316.

[11] LC251/1/2 Hobart Lower Courts 1850-1854, DI 1117, 10th December 1853. 337. Female Convicts database, Eliza Thompson per Lord Auckland, 1848. FCRC convict ID 7826

[12] Launceston Examiner, 21 February 1844, p 3.

[13] Snowden, p. 65, citing AOT, CON 52/7, pp. 175–183 (Hayes/Handley); CON 41/26 and CON 15/6 (Butler); RGD 37/13, 1854, Campbell Town, No. 94

[14] Snowden, pp. 65–66, citing AOT, RGD 37/8, 1849 (Hobart), No. 404; RGD 35/4, 1855, Hobart, No. 255

[15] Snowden, p. 69, citing AOT, CON 50/1, Memorial of Richard March; CON 52/3, p. 305; RGD 37/9, 1850, No. 466.

[16] Snowden, p. 65, citing AOT, CON 52/7, pp. 175–183 (Hayes/Handley); CON 41/26 and CON 15/6 (Butler); RGD 37/13, 1854, Campbell Town, No. 94